Accepted by whom? On the empirical roots of Aristotle's dialectic (Articolo in rivista)

Type
Label
  • Accepted by whom? On the empirical roots of Aristotle's dialectic (Articolo in rivista) (literal)
Anno
  • 2014-01-01T00:00:00+01:00 (literal)
Alternative label
  • Paglieri, Fabio (2014)
    Accepted by whom? On the empirical roots of Aristotle's dialectic
    in Revue internationale de philosophie
    (literal)
Http://www.cnr.it/ontology/cnr/pubblicazioni.owl#autori
  • Paglieri, Fabio (literal)
Pagina inizio
  • 393 (literal)
Pagina fine
  • 402 (literal)
Http://www.cnr.it/ontology/cnr/pubblicazioni.owl#numeroVolume
  • 270 (literal)
Rivista
Http://www.cnr.it/ontology/cnr/pubblicazioni.owl#affiliazioni
  • CNR-ISTC (literal)
Titolo
  • Accepted by whom? On the empirical roots of Aristotle's dialectic (literal)
Abstract
  • In the Topics, Aristotle offers a definition of dialectical reasoning that hinges on its premises being \"generally accepted\". I argue that this characterization of dialectic is not only conceptually problematic, but also empirically untenable. This does not undermine Aristotle's general project in the Topics, as it is more concerned on how to use generally accepted premises effectively in arguments and less on how to define dialectical reasoning in the first place. However, reflecting on Aristotle's problematic definition of dialectic offers insight on the frequent underestimation of empirical debts in philosophy, as well as on how contemporary theories of argument have moved away from the Aristotelian characterization of dialectic - and rightly so. (literal)
Prodotto di
Autore CNR
Insieme di parole chiave

Incoming links:


Autore CNR di
Prodotto
Http://www.cnr.it/ontology/cnr/pubblicazioni.owl#rivistaDi
Insieme di parole chiave di
data.CNR.it